2019 – Cheshire (8-0)

2018 – Cheshire, Shelton (6-2)

2017 – Cheshire (8-0)

2016 – Cheshire (6-2)

2015 – Shelton (8-0)

2014 – Cheshire (8-0)

2013 – Cheshire (7-1)

2012 – Cheshire (8-0)

2011 – Cheshire (8-0)

2010 – Xavier, Cheshire (7-1)

2009 – Cheshire (8-0)

2008 – Shelton (7-1)

2007 – Amity Regional (7-1)

2006 – Amity Regional/Shelton (7-1)

2005 – Shelton (8-0)
2004 – Shelton (8-0)
2003 – Amity Regional (7-1)
2002 – Amity Regional (6-0)
2001 – Amity Regional (6-0)
2000 – Amity Regional (6-0)
1999 – Amity Regional (8-0)
1998 – Amity Regional (8-0)
1997 – Amity Regional (8-0)
1996 – Amity Regional, Daniel Hand (7-1)