2023 (2)

Div. I – Cheshire

Div. II – Daniel Hand

2022 (1)

Div. I – Fairfield Prep; Cheshire runner-up

2021 (2)

Div. I – Fairfield Prep

Div. II – Daniel Hand

2020 – season cancelled due to COVID-19

2019 (1)

Div. II – Daniel Hand

2018 – none

2017 (1)

Div. I – Xavier

2016 (0)

Div. I – Xavier runner-up; Div. II – Notre Dame runner-up

2015 (0)

Div. II – Notre Dame runner-up

2014 (1)

Div. II – Notre Dame

2013 (1)

Div. II – Daniel Hand

2012 (1)

Div. II – Daniel Hand

2011 – none

2010 – none

2009 – none

2008 – none

2007 – none

2006 – none

2005 (0)

Div. III – Daniel Hand runner-up

2004 – none

2003 (1)

Div. I – Hamden

2002 (0)

Div. I – Cheshire runner-up

2001 (0)

Div. I – Notre Dame/Fairfield Prep runners-up

2000 – none

1999 (1)

Div. I – Cheshire

1998 (0)

Div. I – Fairfield Prep runner-up

1997 – none

1996 (1)

Div. I – Amity Regional

1995 (1)

Div. I – Fairfield Prep